04 October 2022
Reading time: 5 minutes
Thermostatic mixing valves are temperature control elements commonly found in shower valves and plumbed into sensor taps controlling the mix of hot and cold water at the point of use. These elements protect users from scalding and manage the temperature at a safe level. These mixing valves are typically classified as TMV2 and/or TMV3.
But if these valves classified as TMV2 or TMV3 both do the same thing, then what is the difference between the two?
The Dolphin mixer tap and shower valve range include TMV2 and/or TMV3 thermostatic mixing valves, and in addition, our ALAVO behind mirror system has an integrated TMV3 Dolphin valve.
In this article, we will explain:
1. How does a TMV work?
Depending on the set water temperature, the element within the thermostatic mixing valve expands or contracts and changes the proportion of hot and cold water mixed in the valve.
If the cold water supply shuts off, the valve swiftly closes the hot water supply to prevent users from scalding themselves.
2. What is a TMV2 mixing valve?
TMV2 valves operate the same way as TMV3 valves with a maximum temperature stop and temperature regulator that copes with high water supply conditions. However, the difference is this thermostatic mixing valve must conform to British Standards as specified in BS EN 1111 and BS EN 1287.
The NSF TMV2 approval Scheme provides an easy approval guide that refers to testing, pre-approval requirements, recommended maximum mixed water outlet temperatures, operating conditions, full and factored approval, and details about the information and maintenance documentation.
TMV2 mixing valves are used in domestic settings, small business premises, and commercial or public buildings. The maximum static water pressure can withstand up to 10 bar in line with BS EN 1111 and BS EN 1287 requirements. The high flow pressure for hot and cold applies to BS EN 1111 and must be between 0.5 and 5.0 bar, whereas the low flow pressure for hot and cold applies to BS EN 1287 and must be between 0.1 and 1.0 bar.
3. What is a TMV3 mixing valve?
A TMV3 mixing valve is certified to comply with NHS requirements issued by the Department of Health in the Health Technical Memorandum 04-01: Supplement – Performance specification D 08: thermostatic mixing valves (healthcare premises), 2017 edition. A third party tests and approves TMV3 valves to ensure they conform to the construction, sampling, leaktightness, durability, designation, installation and operating instructions, commissioning and in-service tests requirements, marking, and performance.
TMV3 valves are a legal requirement for UK healthcare premises but are also suitable for washrooms in commercial developments such as office buildings and public environments.
These mixing valves have enhanced thermal performance features and a temperature stop that allow a quick response time to loss of water pressure or changes in water temperature. TMV3 valves can also cope with extreme supply conditions and work at a maximum static water pressure range of up to 10 bar. High flow pressure for hot and cold ranges from 1 – 5 bar, and low flow pressure ranges from 0.2 to 1 bar.
4. Clearing up the TMV2 and TMV3 debate
Here is a simple table to demonstrate the minor differences between TMV2 and TMV3 pressure conditions:
High pressure conditions for normal use as per NSF TMV2 approval guide and UK Health Department:
High pressure TMV2 (BS EN 1111) | High pressure NHS requirements TMV3 | |
---|---|---|
Maximum static pressure | 10 bar | 10 bar |
Flow pressure, hot and cold | Between 0.5 and 5.0 bar | Between 1 and 5 bar |
Hot supply temperature | Between 55⁰C and 65⁰C | Between 55⁰C and 65⁰C |
Cold supply temperature | Up to 25⁰C | Between 5⁰C and 20⁰C |
Low pressure conditions for normal use as per NSF TMV2 approval guide and UK Health Department:
Low pressure TMV2 (BS EN 1287) | Low pressure NHS requirements TMV3 | |
---|---|---|
Maximum static pressure | 10 bar | 10 bar |
Flow pressure, hot and cold | Between 0.1 and 1.0 bar | Between 0.2 and 1 bar |
Hot supply temperature | Between 55⁰C and 65⁰C | Between 55⁰C and 65⁰C |
Cold supply temperature | Up to 25⁰C | Between 5⁰C and 20⁰C |
As you can see, the differences between the conditions of the thermostatic mixing valves are slight. But the TMV topic is still creating much confusion amongst architects, contractors, building officials, and health engineers, leading them to believe that TMV3 valves are considerably better than TMV2 and more suited for Doc M washrooms.
TMV3 valves are only mandatory for healthcare environments, whereas TMV2 valves are perfectly suitable for commercial and public washrooms because they meet the Harmonised British Standards, making them compliant with the UK Building Regulations.
BS 8300-2:2018 – Design of an accessible and inclusive built environment – Part 2: Buildings – Code of practice, stipulates “The temperature of hot water supply at an outlet can be controlled by use of an appropriate in-line blending valve or other temperature control device in accordance with either BS EN 1111 or BS EN 1287.”
BS8300 also specifies that the temperature at the outlet must not exceed 43⁰C for basin taps and shower fittings and the temperature of the water circulating in the pipework must be at least 60°C to avoid the risk of Legionella.
This means that the standard of TMV2 valves meets the BS 8300 requirements, and there should be no concerns about the functionality or compliance of this valve when developing a commercial washroom.
5. Accessible washrooms and thermostatic mixers
There is a misunderstanding that accessible washrooms in commercial buildings must incorporate TMV3 valves for taps and showers because there is a relationship between healthcare and accessibility. This is not true.
There is no connection between accessible washrooms in commercial buildings and healthcare environments, and the UK Department of Health does not require TMV3 valves to be installed in commercial accessible washrooms.
When designing accessible washrooms, Document Part M of the Building Regulations stipulates that these washrooms must comply with BS 8300 standards – BS 8300 standards refer to BS EN 1111 and BS EN 1287. Thus, TMV2 valves conform to the relevant building regulations within the washroom environment and are acceptable for installation in commercial accessible washrooms.
6. TMV and WELL standards
The WELL standard requires a thermostatic mixing valve for taps that blend hot and cold water at the point of use to enhance washroom accommodations.
Learn more about the Hygiene checklist for a WELL certified washroom.
7. Which TMV is suitable for your washroom?
A TMV2 is suitable and compliant with UK Building Regulations for any standard commercial washroom. But within the healthcare sector, it is mandatory to install TMV3 valves as specified by the UK Department of Health performance specification D 08.
Both thermostatic mixing valves are measured and tested in different ways according to each of their standards, therefore it is not possible to make a fair or direct comparison on which one is better.
The British Building Regulations have authority over TMV2 standards, and the UK Department of Health has authority over TMV3 regulations. But remember, this does not mean one TMV is more compliant than the other. Both TMVs are compliant, but the only exception is that TMV3 valves are a legal requirement for UK healthcare premises.
We hope we have put your mind at ease by addressing this controversial topic and have equipped you with enough information to make a better-informed decision regarding thermostatic mixing valves.